This fall, our village will experience a significant change in how we manage fallen leaves. On April 30, the village board decided to switch from the current system, where residents rake leaves into the street for collection, to a leaf-bagging system.
The decision to transition to a leaf-bagging system was made with good intentions, focused on safety, but the potential implications and challenges it brings cannot be overlooked. These concerns, along with the inherent complexities of such a transition, informed my decision to vote No. I would have liked us to consider additional solutions that do not introduce the concerns I raise below while attempting to solve for safety.
Equity Concerns: One of my primary concerns is the disproportionate impact this policy will have on our senior and disabled residents. Bagging leaves requires physical effort that may not be feasible for everyone, potentially making it harder for these community members to manage independently. This change could significantly affect our community’s inclusivity, especially for those who wish to age in place comfortably and safely.
Increased Costs: The transition to leaf bagging also means increased costs. Residents will now need to purchase bags, or the village will have to provide these bags. We will also spend more time and effort cleaning up and bagging leaves, or pay for this service. These additional costs, some obvious and some hidden, have not been fully quantified yet. Ultimately, these expenses will be reflected in our taxes or in direct out-of-pocket costs for materials and services.
Sustainability Implications: Although there are potential environmental benefits to bagging leaves, such as reducing the risk of blocked drains and less street cleaning required, I am concerned about the long-term impact on our community’s relationship with trees. Viewing trees as a chore rather than a benefit can alter community perceptions and future decisions negatively. Additionally, the increase in material manufacturing and use (bags) and the uptick in bagging equipment use does not align with or contribute to our sustainability goals.
Nonetheless, now that the majority has spoken and the decision has been made, I encourage all residents to support the transition to this new program and make it as smooth and painless as possible. Please support your neighbors who may need a helping hand and also be patient with the village and each other as we work through this.
Stay tuned for more communication from the village on the specifics of this program.
Ravi Parakkat is a trustee on the Oak Park Village Board.
